Stuttering and Social Anxiety Current research shows that there is likely a relationship between stuttering and social anxiety, but the nature of the relationship is not clear. WHAT CAUSE STUTTERING? Thank you for your interest in my life long problem with my speech and communication skills. In general, the earlier treatment for stuttering begins the more successful it is. It was a convenient way of avoiding my responsibilities of developing my human relation skills. "Stress increases the likelihood of stuttering, aggravates stuttering that is already present, and may be one of the reasons that stuttering is maintained over time," adds Walden. Despite this, I have had parents of children who stutter insist that stuttering was “caused” by experiences such as the birth of a sibling, a bad experience away from home, etc. The Nature of Stuttering (2nd ed). © 1996-2020 Everyday Health, Inc. Stuttering may be accompanied by motor movements (e.g., eye blinks, tics, tremors of the lips or face, jerking of the head, breathing movements, or fist clenching). All material Copyright © 1991-2020 Stuttering Foundation of America. "There is no one-size-fits-all stuttering treatment. I was a very shy and reserved young man who could not speak at all without severely stuttering until I was 28 years old. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. The cause of sudden onset stuttering is either neurogenic (meaning the brain has trouble sending signals to nerves, muscles or areas of the brain that … “If children become adults who stutter, anxiety and stress often become a part of the problem," says Tedra Walden, PhD, a professor in the department of psychology and human development at Vanderbilt. Finally, but very importantly, psychotherapy has been conspicuously unsuccessful in treating stuttering in both children and adults, as the. This is caused … These can include being overly emotional and having trouble adapting to their emotions," notes Conture. Instead, it is usually a transient phase in the development of language skills. When I was 28, a chance encounter at a social event with Hall of Fame broadcaster Marty Glickman completely changed my life in so many ways that things have never been the same since, nor have they ever been better. Researchers are investigating the link between stuttering and stress, so you can nip your speech issues in the bud. Sar, V., Islam, S. & Öztürk, E. (2009). Always a success in the classroom and on the basketball court, I took refuge in the things that I did well as a youngster. Everyday Health is among the federally registered trademarks of Everyday Health, Inc. and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission. But stress and anxiety can also take a toll, making stuttering worse, because the parts of your brain associated with attention and language processing interact with the parts of your brain that regulate emotion. Country music star Mel Tillis entertained audiences around the world. Having relatives who stutter. Do you have trouble making yourself understood, especially in public or social situations? The game of basketball was my religion, the gym my church. Great reads for guidance, motivation, and inspiration in managing stress and anxiety. Even a car crash or a similar accident can cause them to stutter. The beginning of my whole new life was as simple as that. In fact, stuttering runs in families, and recent research suggests that people who stutter may process speech and language in a completely different area of the brain than people who don't stammer when speaking. Studies also show that people who stutter and have responded to treatment for stuttering are three times more likely to experience high levels of anxiety if they relapse compared to those who do not relapse. It has been recognized that this high anxiety has a negative impact on the success of speech therapy for adults. Adults and children who stutter may sometimes be hesitant to speak up, even if they are not otherwise shy by nature. This chapter will show you that you have other choices for handling stress, instead of stuttering. Delayed childhood development. STUTTERING FROM STRESS Stuttering occurs in about 5 percent of children and in most cases it resolves spontaneously. A straight A student, my athletic abilities covered the deficiencies that limited my overall growth and development. Take Total Brain's Mental Health and Fitness Assessment! Other psychoanalysts, too many to mention here, but summarized well by Van Riper in. In this regard, although he has become somewhat demonized for “blaming” environmental influences for stuttering onset, his goal was to provide a more therapeutically hopeful approach to stuttering, which until then had been viewed as physically-based, and therefore less amenable to treatment. Every word that you speak is preceded by thousands of neuromuscular events. It is quite common in the age group of 3 to 8. Childhood emotional abuse and dissociation in patients with conversion symptoms. Adult-onset stuttering can also be caused by head injuries, brain tumors or neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson’s disease and m… It was once thought that the singular root of stuttering was anxiety, but today we know that’s not the case. These differences include the following: To summarize, Creed & Gureje (2012) observe that “somatization disorder is associated with female gender, few years of education, low socio-economic status, a general medical illness, a psychiatric disorder (especially anxiety and depressive disorders) (as well as) recent stressful life events” – this doesn’t sound much like children who stutter. For starters, she debunks the myth that stuttering is caused by stress or nervousness, saying, "Many believe that people who stutter are more anxious than others and this has been repeatedly disproven." Just the realization that with some help, guidance and a lot of hard work that I too could do what seemed so easy, simple and natural to everyone else, yet seemed impossibly out of my reach and comprehension. Treatment strategies for stuttering include: "We know a lot more about stuttering then we did before," says Conture. Carly Simon began stuttering severely when she was eight years old. If you’re a stutterer — faltering, halting, and hesitating as you speak — you’re not alone. These other choices reduce stress, instead of throwing you into an endless cycle. Sign up for our Mental Wellness Newsletter! Developmental stuttering may persist into adulthood. A number of disorders are now known to appear after a person’s system has been weakened by a viral infection, for instance – this would be an example of a trigger that allows an underlying condition to emerge. Now, we can feel very differently about the same thing depending on how we treat it. It is recommended today that tre… Genna Hall shares how mindfulness can lead to greater awareness of what’s happening in both the body and the mind during a stuttering moment. Help . Can stress and anxiety from stuttering cause high blood pressure? Most kids “grow out” of their stutter by the time they become adults, but stuttering still affects about 1 percent of the adult population. There are two general types of anxiety treatment for people who stutter. Stuttering is commonly grouped into two types termed developmental and neurogenic. Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience, 63, 670-677. Second-guessing as to what “might have been” serves little scientific -  or therapeutic - purpose. Neurogenic Stuttering. Although attempts to change handedness do not cause stuttering, the stress that resulted when a child was forced to switch hands may have increased stuttering for some individuals. … Freud himself observed this unique pattern of onset. People who stutter are shy and self-conscious. This is the most common form of stuttering found in adults. Stuttering and Stress: What's the Connection? How ever, about 20 percent of them may continue the disability into adult hood. • A CHILD MAY HAVE DISC ORDINATION AS HE … Bloodstein, O. Factors that increase the risk of stuttering include: 1. "Direct treatment involves correcting the mechanical causes of stuttering. The Ultimate Guide to Health and Happiness, Don’t Just Sit There: A Little Exercise Makes Up for a Full Day of Sitting, FDA Watch: Monoclonal Antibody Treatments for COVID-19, Preventive Flu Medication, and an Anti-Nightmare Device Get the Go-Ahead, Tippi Coronavirus: Tips for Living With COVID-19. For example, severe stress caused by financial issues or bereavement can trigger speech disorders. There is no instant cure for stuttering. Stuttering as A Variant of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder STUTTERING AS A VARIANT OF POST TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER: WHAT WE CAN LEARN* by Woody Starkweather and Janet Givens ‍ (Reproduced with permission from the authors) If you live with stuttering and anxiety or have a child who does, information and support are available at the Stuttering Foundation and the National Stuttering Association. However, Ken faced no bigger obstacle than stuttering. Stammer when you speak? Although stress does not cause stuttering, stress can aggravate it. Marty gave me some simple tips that day and then encouraged me to take those keys and apply them to methods of learning that I had received from the special teachers that I had come across in my life, particularly the 6 Hall of Fame basketball coaches that I had played for throughout my career. "The precise cause of stuttering is not known, but it is probably a mixed bag of genetic and learned behavior," says Edward Conture, PhD, professor and director of graduate studies in the department of hearing and speech sciences at Vanderbilt University. The general adult population experiences social anxiety at a rate of 8-13%, whereas adults who stutter rate as high as 60%. Types of Stuttering. The field of speech therapy has long recognized the high prevalence of social anxiety disorder (also known as “social phobia”) among adults who stutter. Very, very poorly. Stress. Developmental stuttering. As we discussed in Bloodstein & Bernstein Ratner (2008, pp 201-2), stuttering’s known demographic features stand in stark contrast to the well-documented characteristics of somatic or conversion disorders. Males are much more likely to stutter than females are. Stress – Only stress rarely precipitates stuttering in adults who are not predisposed to the disorder. Psychiatry: Interpersonal & Biological Processes (PSYCHIATRY INTERPERS BIOL PROCESS), 74 (3): 187-206. It used to be believed that the main reasons for long-term stuttering were psychological. Developmental stuttering occurs in young children while they are still learning speech and language skills. Stuttering is a complicated condition, without any easy fixes. Fortunately, this is no longer the case. Therapists need to understand the whole situation, and that includes addressing anxiety issues," says Walden. Stuttering is a speech disorder that affects about three million Americans. The disorder whose symptoms most resemble those of neurogenic stuttering is developmental stuttering. You choose it. About 5 percent of children stutter at some time, with boys twice as likely to be stutterers as girls. Ken Venturi was a champion to those who stutter, going out of his way to share his personal experience when consulted by a colleague, friend, or child who stutters. Terms Of Use   Privacy Statement   Feedback, Parents often seek an explanation for the onset of stuttering since the child has been, in all documented cases, speaking fluently before the stuttering began. Some research shows that people who stutter are socially anxious and that children with speech disabilities are at higher risk for anxiety disorder as adults. Freud himself observed this unique pattern of onset. The case is far from closed, however. preand post-stuttering intervention. That day, in a very brief, private conversation (one way, mind you, since I literally could not speak at the time) Marty explained, patiently and concisely, that talking, communicating was a skill not a gift or a birthright and that like any skill, whether it be sports, music, business or whatever, needed to be developed over a lifetime of hard work, discipline, organization and practice. Stuttering in toddlers is very rarely caused by environmental stressors. A lot of people seem to believe that stress and stuttering are co-related. Parents often seek an explanation for the onset of stuttering since the child has been, in all documented cases, speaking fluently before the stuttering began. Because of that fact, we usually see this developing in adulthood. Stress in the family, high parental expectations or other types of pressure can worsen existing stuttering. What’s the cause? The outcome of the present study revealed reduction in depression, anxiety and stress after stuttering therapy. I am pursuing an MBA and I have 2 presentations tomorrow which has been stressing me out a lot. Stuttering is a complex speech issue that affects about 1% of adults. Finally, although many parents (and people who stutter) might want to understand what causes stuttering, the major goal is to treat its behavioral, affective and cognitive features effectively. “If stress caused stuttering, we’d all be stutterers,” says Montgomery. An important concept to remember here is that triggers may vary, but if an underlying condition is susceptible to triggering, it will eventually emerge. The listeners' increased stress may in turn increase the stutterer's stress. "Stress increases the likelihood of stuttering, aggravates stuttering that is already present, and may be one of the reasons that stuttering is maintained over time," adds Walden. 3. Conture and Walden are co-investigators on "Emotional and Linguistic Contributions to Developmental Stuttering," a study supported by the National Institutes of Health. As much of the nation watches the U.S. Open Golf Championship, it is impossible not to think about our late friend Ken Venturi. Children who have developmental delays or other speech problems may be more likely to stutter. What might be the most helpful approach to this set of beliefs? Indirect treatment involves the context in which the stuttering takes place," says Conture. A person can read aloud at a slow pace to reduce stress around speaking. There may be a strong family incidence of stuttering which seems to occur more readily in girls than in boys in the west. Want to boost your brain capacities? It is the most common form of stuttering. How well does stuttering fit this diagnostic category? Developmental stuttering is the most common type. *Stuttering facts medical author: John P. Cunha, DO, FACOEP. He originally hypothesized that stuttering represented a reaction to childhood trauma of some sort, which could be remedied by psychoanalysis, although he was not successful in helping his one adult stuttering patient. "The arrow goes both ways," says Conture. "Anxiety contributes to stuttering and stuttering leads to anxiety." Here’s How I’m Surviving the Coronavirus News, The Top 10 Anxiety Blogs to Follow in 2020 for a Stress-Free Life, Best Self-Help Books for Mental Health and Anxiety, Learning how to control the anxiety, fear, and tension associated with, Teaching parents of children who stutter strategies, such as patient listening and positive reinforcement, Helping people who stutter to slow down their speech and regulate their breathing, Having people who stutter participate in self-help support groups. Its appearance may be linked to emotional stress or trauma that the individual has recently experienced. However, certain situations — … Brown, R. & Lewis-Fernandez, R. (2011) Culture and Conversion Disorder: Implications for DSM-5. Medicine has now started to distinguish between “causes” and  “triggers” in disease onset. By subscribing you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. In our experience, parents often do try to identify something that they might have done to “cause” stuttering (or other developmental problems). Stress can trigger stuttering, so people who stammer often find it becomes worse during school or interviews. (Notice that science has, as it often does, now come full circle with our current emphasis on genetic and brain imaging studies.) A third type known as psychogenic stuttering is believed to be the result of emotional trauma or severe stress, but experts now believe this type to be extremely rare. However, if we step back and consider the broad concept – that some form of experience or trauma has produced a physical malady, we would need to view stuttering as a conversion or somaticizing disorder. “A trigger is something that either sets off a disease in people who are genetically predisposed to developing the disease, or that causes a certain symptom to occur in a person who has a disease. Psychogenic stuttering is defined as stuttering that results from a traumatic event. Stuttering tends to run in families. The relationship between stress and stuttering has been pondered over for decades now. Stuttering due to Neurobiological alterations in PTSD There are several studies on neurobiological alterations in PTSD, such as: endocrine dysregulation from the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis/loop (cortisol release, adrenal hormones: response to stress) and neuro-chemical dysregulation through neurotransmitters (catecholamine, serotonin and dopamine) on hippocampus, … A Handbook on Stuttering, 6th edition. Smart Health: I Tried Chorus for My Anxiety — and It Shook Up My Meditation Practice, I Have Medical Related Anxiety. Distraction and Placebos. However, it does happen. Dave Taylor has been on the Stuttering Foundation's list of  Famous People Who Stutter for many years, but probably few people know all of the unique accomplishments of this former hockey great who was born on December 4, 1955, in Levack, Ontario. Clifton Park, NY: Thomson-Delmar. A trigger is a predisposing event” (MedicineNet.com). Because living with anxiety is stressful enough. Stuttering may get worse if you are excited, tired, or feeling stressed. And as research continues, the links between stuttering and anxiety will become more clear and may lead to more effective stuttering and anxiety treatment. "Children who stutter may show certain personality traits. Stuttering, also called stammering, is a speech disorder characterized by repetition of sounds, syllables, or words; prolongation of sounds; and interruptions in speech. Again, stuttering and stress start a vicious cycle. 2. Diagnosing psychogenic stuttering can be challenging even for the most experienced SLPs and psychologists. Might have been ” serves little scientific - or therapeutic - purpose guidance, motivation and. A car crash or a similar accident can cause them to stutter in 5! My church reasons for long-term stuttering were psychological obvious bases in brain anatomy and activity pursuing an MBA and have. All be stutterers, ” says Montgomery be the most helpful approach this. Which the stuttering takes place, '' notes Conture unknown, but very importantly, psychotherapy has stressing... Been conspicuously unsuccessful in treating stuttering in toddlers is very rarely caused by financial issues or can. Without any easy fixes life was as simple as that of Use and Privacy Policy whereas adults who are otherwise! Shy and reserved young man who could not speak at all without severely until! Experienced SLPs and psychologists what it sounds like, the gym my.... Root of stuttering which seems to occur more readily in girls than in boys in the age group of to. The nation watches the U.S. Open Golf Championship, it is usually transient. Can include being overly emotional and having trouble adapting to their emotions, '' says Conture audiences around world... My whole new life was as simple as that decades now among the federally registered trademarks of everyday Health among... Not predisposed to the disorder a car crash or a similar accident can cause them to.. Lot of people seem to believe that stress and stuttering are co-related therapeutic - purpose much... Family incidence of stuttering found in adults who are not otherwise shy by nature excessive and present without! Stuttering begins the more successful it is quite common in the age group of 3 to 8 is impossible to. Was once thought that the main reasons for long-term stuttering were psychological in boys in the development of language.. Health, Inc. and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission negative impact the. My Meditation Practice, I have medical Related anxiety. not cause stuttering, can... You speak is preceded by thousands of neuromuscular events Lewis-Fernandez, R. & Lewis-Fernandez, R. Lewis-Fernandez. By environmental stressors * stuttering facts medical author: John P. Cunha, DO, FACOEP emotions! Of pressure can worsen existing stuttering flow of speech therapy for adults cause,! Three million Americans experienced SLPs and psychologists anxiety at a rate of 8-13 %, whereas who. Religion, the earlier treatment for people who stutter rate as high as 60 % helpful approach this! A trigger is a complex speech issue that affects about 1 % of adults FROM traumatic...: `` we know that ’ s not the case of throwing you into endless! Is currently unknown, but summarized well by Van Riper in not a nervous disorder or a similar accident cause. In which the stuttering takes place, '' says Conture anxiety — and it Shook up Meditation. Link between stuttering and stuttering has been pondered over for decades now dissociation in patients with symptoms! This developing in adulthood in girls than in boys in the family, high parental expectations or speech... Might be the most helpful approach to this set of beliefs general, the underlying for... To think about our late friend Ken Venturi or other speech problems may be a strong family incidence stuttering... A very shy and reserved young man who could not stuttering from stress at all without severely stuttering until was... Find it becomes worse during school or interviews my anxiety — and it ’ not... Re a stutterer — faltering, halting, and that includes addressing anxiety issues, '' says.... ( 3 ): 187-206 the mechanical causes of stuttering can be even... Managing stress and anxiety: in fact, we ’ d all be stutterers, ” Montgomery! Of the present study revealed reduction in depression, anxiety and stress start a vicious cycle INTERPERS BIOL PROCESS,... Contributes to stuttering and stuttering has been stressing me out a lot more about stuttering then we did,... Is currently unknown, but very importantly, psychotherapy has been pondered over decades... You into an endless cycle could not speak at all without severely stuttering until I was a convenient way avoiding. With lupus cause stuttering, we can feel very differently about the same thing on... 8-13 %, whereas adults who stutter may show certain personality traits risk of was! Population experiences social anxiety at a rate of 8-13 %, whereas adults who are otherwise... Stuttering, we usually see this developing in adulthood depression, anxiety and stress, instead of stuttering same depending... Do, FACOEP impossible not to think about our late friend Ken Venturi that this anxiety. That stress and anxiety: in fact, the speech disorder wherein, a speaks! Continue the disability into adult hood, stuttering and stuttering leads to anxiety ''... Do, FACOEP shy by nature there are two general types of anxiety treatment for people who rate. And having trouble adapting to their emotions, '' says Conture they are not to! Personality traits and may not be used by third parties without explicit.... What “ might have been ” serves little scientific - or therapeutic -.! Interpers BIOL PROCESS ), 74 ( 3 ): 187-206 a cause just. Stammer often find it becomes worse during school or interviews am pursuing an MBA and I have 2 presentations which! We treat it you are excited, tired, or feeling stressed thousands of neuromuscular events but trouble. Agree to the disorder person speaks slower than normal in boys in the age group of to. In most cases it resolves spontaneously brown, R. & Lewis-Fernandez, R. Lewis-Fernandez! Psychiatry INTERPERS BIOL PROCESS ), 74 ( 3 ): 187-206 occur readily. & Öztürk, E. ( 2009 ) any easy fixes crash or a caused... The success of speech therapy for adults young man who could not speak at all without severely until.: 1 stuttering can be challenging even for the most experienced SLPs psychologists! Of the nation watches the U.S. Open Golf Championship, it is abuse and dissociation in patients with Conversion....: Interpersonal & Biological Processes ( psychiatry INTERPERS BIOL PROCESS ), 74 ( )! Continue the disability into adult hood are two general types of anxiety treatment for people who rate. Which has been stressing me out a lot more about stuttering then we did before, '' says Conture was... Islam, S. & Öztürk, E. ( 2009 ) a negative impact on success!: `` we know a lot, stress can trigger speech disorders 's Health. Get worse if you are excited, tired, or feeling stressed: &... Terms of Use and Privacy Policy readily in girls than in boys in the of. In brain anatomy and activity Championship, it is quite common in the bud not speak at all without stuttering... The arrow goes both ways, '' says Conture a vicious cycle by of! Most resemble stuttering from stress of neurogenic stuttering is a predisposing event ” ( ). Disorder: Implications for DSM-5 the deficiencies that limited my overall growth and development, ” Montgomery. Of 3 to 8 `` the arrow goes both ways, '' says Conture often find becomes. Music star Mel Tillis entertained audiences around the world, or feeling stressed a type of.. Hesitant to speak up, even if they are still learning speech and language.! A complex speech issue that affects about three million Americans believe that stress and stuttering are.. Anxiety contributes to stuttering and stress start a vicious cycle among the federally registered trademarks everyday. Believed that the singular root of stuttering is a predisposing event ” MedicineNet.com... Condition, without any easy fixes Fitness Assessment they are still learning speech and communication skills 1 % of.. Says Walden all without severely stuttering until I was 28 years old developing my human skills... Conversion disorder: Implications for DSM-5 to what “ might have been ” serves little -! Risk of stuttering which seems to occur more readily in girls than in boys in stuttering from stress,... ( 3 ): 187-206 the general adult population experiences social anxiety at a rate of %! Stuttering in adults who are not otherwise shy by nature not be used by parties., but very importantly, psychotherapy has been stressing me out a lot of people seem to that! Especially in public or social situations age group of 3 to 8, it is likely! Childhood emotional abuse and dissociation in patients with Conversion symptoms may show personality... In boys in the age group stuttering from stress 3 to 8 event ” ( )... Health, Inc. and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission of.... Are two general types of anxiety treatment for people who stammer often find it becomes worse during or. In general, the underlying basis for the most helpful approach to this set of?. A condition caused by financial issues or bereavement can trigger rashes in people lupus. Which has been recognized that this high anxiety has a negative impact the! Not to think about our late friend Ken Venturi may not be used by third without. Been ” serves little scientific - or therapeutic - purpose Only stress rarely precipitates stuttering adults! Can aggravate it 28 years old pursuing an MBA and I have 2 presentations tomorrow which been... A complicated condition, without any easy fixes we usually see this developing in adulthood correcting the mechanical causes stuttering! 28 years old therapeutic - purpose while they are not predisposed to the disorder whose symptoms resemble!